In digital marketing, every click, every visit, and every piece of content you create has one ultimate goal: to drive some sort of meaningful conversion.
Whether you want users to sign up for a newsletter, download a guide, or make a purchase, your call to action (CTA) is the bridge between interest and conversion. But too often, brands make critical mistakes that render their CTAs ineffective — meaning their content doesn't convert.
After analyzing hundreds of websites over the years, I’ve noticed a pattern. Even strong brands with solid content strategies and marketing teams repeatedly fall into the same conversion pitfalls. They drive relevant traffic, but they don’t get anyone to take action.
The result? Missed opportunities and underperforming marketing campaigns (which aren’t cheap).
The good news is these mistakes are totally fixable. Let’s break down the five biggest CTA mistakes that are killing your conversions — and exactly how to fix them.
One of the biggest mistakes brands make with their calls to action (CTAs) is failing to align them with the visitor’s intent and stage of awareness. A company might invest heavily in high-quality content and see a steady stream of traffic, but if the CTA doesn’t match what the visitor actually needs at that moment, conversion rates will suffer.
Too often, brands default to bottom-of-funnel CTAs, like “Request a Demo,” “Start a Free Trial,” or “Add to Cart” across all of their content, regardless of the visitor’s intent. While these CTAs are effective (and appropriate) in the right context, they aren’t suitable for every visitor in every stage.
Let’s say you run an email marketing platform like MailChimp or ConvertKit. Visitors may reach your site with different questions and goals, depending on which piece of content they land on. Let’s look at a few examples:
The fix here is simple: use contextual and stage-appropriate CTAs. Instead of treating every visitor the same, map your CTAs to the visitor’s intent and their stage in the buyer’s journey.
If they aren’t ready to buy yet, give them an easy next step that requires less commitment, like opting in to download an industry report or using a (gated) interactive tool. If they’re already actively comparing solutions, don’t hesitate to push for a bottom-of-funnel conversion.
{{inline-cta-conversion-killer="/style-guide-elements"}}
A well-written, in-depth article might rank well in search results, but if your sole CTA is always buried at the bottom, most readers will never see it. Research shows that web visitors don’t usually read every word — they skim.
According to UX researcher Harold Weinrich, web users only read about 20% of a page’s text on average.
A separate study from Chartbeat and Slate found that visitors typically interact with only 60% of a page, with engagement concentrated just below the fold.
In other words, if your only CTA is sitting at the end of a long-form article, most readers won’t make it that far.
There are several strategies for placing CTAs throughout your content so they don’t get overlooked:
Sticky Sidebar CTA: A call to action that stays visible as the reader scrolls. (Example: databox.com)
Pinned Alert Bar: A subtle notification at the top or bottom of the page that grabs attention without being intrusive (Example: Simplisafe.com)
Inline CTAs: Embed calls to action midway through articles where engagement is highest. (Example: tebra.com)
Shoppable Product Boxes: For e-commerce, placing interactive product CTAs throughout blog content increases the likelihood of conversion. (Example: madeincookware.com)
CTA in the Header or Intro: In some cases, placing a CTA at the very beginning of the content can work well, because it guarantees visibility. (Example: vwo.com)
Instead of employing a single CTA at the end, test multiple CTA placements throughout your content. A good rule is to introduce a CTA early, reinforce it in the middle, and repeat it at the end in a way that feels natural.
By making your CTA accessible before a visitor loses interest, you can significantly improve conversion rates, turning visitors who would’ve previously never seen your CTAs into leads.
CTAs are meant to grab attention and drive action, but too often, they blend into the text so much they become nearly invisible.
You’ve probably encountered this before — reading an article, scrolling past a CTA, and not even realizing it was there. If a CTA fails to stand out, it fails to convert.
The key to an effective CTA is contrast. A well-designed CTA should immediately draw the reader’s eye and make it clear what they should do next. Here are some CTA design best practices:
One of the most powerful ways to make a CTA more engaging is by using emotive human faces. We are biologically wired to focus on other people, especially when we sense emotion. Studies show that if we see someone looking at something, we instinctively follow their gaze.
For example, if your CTA features an image of a person making eye contact with the reader or looking toward the CTA button, users are more likely to notice and engage with it. This is a small but powerful tweak that can significantly increase click-through rates.
The best CTAs command attention with proper design and placement. Test different design elements, colors, and images to see what best captures engagement. If your CTA doesn’t stand out at a quick glance, it’s time to rethink its design.
{{inline-cta-conversion-killer="/style-guide-elements"}}
Every extra step you add to the conversion process will typically lead to more visitors bouncing, lowering your conversion rate. Here are a few common sources of friction:
To reduce friction, focus on simplicity and speed:
Friction kills conversions. Every extra click, unnecessary field, or second of hesitation can cost you potential customers. Streamlining your conversion process will remove obstacles and help people take action.
How many times have you landed on a website with a CTA like this:
Vague CTAs often fail to convert — and for good reason. They offer no explanation, no visuals, and no compelling reason to take action. Nobody wakes up in the morning thinking, “I can't wait to subscribe to another newsletter today!” (except perhaps a few people corporate cyborgs on LinkedIn).
A weak offer lacks specificity and perceived value. If visitors don’t immediately understand what they’re getting and why they should care, they’re far less likely to give you their email address (let alone commit to a purchase).
Instead of a generic CTA, make your offer:
Conversion optimization isn’t about luck — it requires strategy and consistent execution. The CTA mistakes outlined above are some of the most common, yet even major brands continue to make them.
By avoiding these pitfalls and applying best practices, you can turn more traffic into leads, and more leads into customers. Here’s a quick recap:
Now, let’s take a look at your website. Where are you losing conversions? Start fixing these CTA mistakes today, and before long, you’ll see the difference in engagement, lead generation, and ultimately revenue.
{{inline-cta-conversion-killer="/style-guide-elements"}}
